Brexit policy panel: April 2019


The UK in a Changing Europe’s Brexit Policy Panel (BPP) is a cross-disciplinary group of more than 100 academics from across the social sciences. It was created to provide ongoing analysis of where we have got to in the Brexit process, and to forecast where we are headed. A full list of members is here.

Members of the BPP complete a monthly survey addressing three key areas of uncertainty around Brexit: if – and when – the UK will leave the EU; how Brexit will affect British politics; and what our relationship with the EU is likely to look like in the future.

  • Brexit experts predict that Labour will top the poll in the European elections held next month, with the Brexit Party in second place
  • Boris Johnson is the academic experts’ frontrunner to be the next leader of the Conservative Party
  • If the UK asks for a further extension to Article 50 in October, a large majority of experts (73%) expect the EU to grant one
  • 87% of our panel are sceptical that Labour and the Conservatives will reach an agreement on the direction of Brexit
  • A majority of our experts – by a margin of 58% to 42% – do not expect Theresa May to still be in office as Prime Minister by 31 October
  • Only 18% of our expert panel think the UK will have left the EU by 31 October

European Parliament elections

There is a significant level of uncertainty and unpredictability around the European elections. We asked our panel to rank parties by how well they would do, using percentage share of the vote as a measure. This survey was conducted prior to the parties launching their campaigns. There was a strong consensus on the panel that Labour were likely to top the poll. There was less consensus further down the list, though overall the panel expected the Brexit Party to come in second place, and for Change UK to be out-performed by the Liberal Democrats.

  1. Labour
  2. Brexit Party
  3. Conservatives
  4. Liberal Democrats
  5. UKIP
  6. ChangeUK
  7. Green
  8. SNP

The next Tory leader

Another key ‘known unknown’ in British politics is who will be the probable replacement for Theresa May if and when she loses the keys to Downing Street. We asked our panel – approximating the methodology used by the Conservative website ConHome – to name the figure most likely to win a future contest. Our panel reaffirm Boris Johnson as the frontrunner, though have a more optimistic view of Jeremy Hunt’s chances than the ConHome survey suggests.

CandidateAcademics’ Prediction (%)Conservative Members – ConHome survey (%)
Boris Johnson34.4%32.4%
Jeremy Hunt15.6%6.5%
Michael Gove 15.6%8.4%
David Lidington4.7%3.5%
Dominic Raab 4.7%14.7%
Amber Rudd3.1%2.0%

 

October Council

A key factor in the Brexit process is whether the European Council summit scheduled for October represents a ‘hard’ deadline for the UK, or whether EU leaders would accept a further extension of Article 50.  Our panel think it is overwhelmingly likely that the EU would grant an extension if the UK required one in the Autumn: 73% said a further extension would be agreed, 27% that it would not.

Only 32% of the panel expect a general election prior to this October deadline. However, a majority of our experts – by a margin of 58% to 42% – do not expect Theresa May to still be in office as Prime Minister by this date.

May-Corbyn negotiations

As the talks between the Labour party and the government rumble on, we asked our panel about the prospects for the negotiations. The panel were sceptical that they would lead to a cross-party agreement and the withdrawal agreement passing through the House of Commons.


Referendum/no deal probability

Looking ahead, our panel put the chances of a further referendum taking place in 2019 at 49%, up from 42% a month ago. The chance of a no deal Brexit has also correspondingly fallen, from 38% to 33%.


We also asked our panel whether, on balance, they felt it was likely that the UK will leave the EU by the latest date of the current Article 50 extension period on 31 October 2019, having passed the withdrawal agreement. While 18% of the panel felt this was likely, 52% felt this was unlikely. 30% said they were unsure.

The future relationship

There has been an upsurge in the expectation that the UK’s trade relationship with the EU will be on the basis of membership of a customs unions – the proportion of our panel who expect this outcome has moved up from 24% to 39% in the last month. The probability that the UK and the EU will end up with a ‘Canada-style’ free-trade agreement is also falling: only 7% of our panel now expect this outcome.

Some 88% of the panel think the December 2020 date pencilled in for future trade talks to end is too optimistic. Only 21% think an agreement on trade could be reached by December 2022, the maximum date negotiations can be extended to in the withdrawal agreement.

The Irish question

The broad expectation that there will be no border on the island of Ireland has also been reaffirmed by the panel: just 9% of our panel now expect any border between the UK and the EU to be ‘North-South’.

You can view the full list of BPP members here.

Disclaimer:
The views expressed in this analysis post are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the UK in a Changing Europe initiative.

View all analyses
x

Subscribe to our fortnightly newsletter

Get a round-up of The UK in a Changing Europe’s latest analysis pieces, videos, explainers, podcasts, reports, events, infographics and more, written by the organisation’s director Anand Menon. PS his mum says it’s "quite good".




Sign up to our newsletter





View our latest newsletter